I first had a try with Garage Band about three years ago. I liked the ease with which I could get started, the editing tools were easy enough to use, the sound libraries are realistic, and even finishing a track was relatively simple. However, after three years of using it on and off, I am using different software for most of my recording needs. Simply put, Garage Band is hard to play.
Let me add a little background to this. I’m a former music teacher, performer and clinician with a Master’s degree. I’ve got more than twenty years experience on three of the instruments I have at my disposal through Garage Band, but I struggle to play them well in this software. Why? They are not idiomatically designed. I just can’t get used to trying to play guitar or bass with my fingertips on a screen, touching to play a note. I’m expecting to finger a note, and strum or pick with the other hand. Here it takes all my fingers just to punch out a decent bass line. Oh, and did I mention that if I don’t hit the note in exactly the right place, the string will bend? Ask any guitar player and they’ll tell you that bends aren’t easy to do, but Garage Band makes it almost necessary to bend if you want to play at all. I miss the feel of the strings on my fingers too.
Now I know that Apple can’t make all those things happen. There isn’t a way, at least not yet, to make the keyboard actually feel like I’m pressing keys, or make guitar chords that feel right. (By the way, these are next to impossible to do by hand.) But I did have a hope that perhaps someone who is an actual musician wouldn’t have to feel like a fool using this software. After many years of playing an instrument, muscle memory takes over. You may not realize it, but you have learned to expect certain position cues, responses and reactions from the instrument that just aren’t there in a virtual capacity. Unless the virtual instrument is an instrument first and a computer controller second, those features may never be there. Whose guitar has only eight frets anyway?
Just as it is important to try and design music performance software that will actually be musical, it is important to make these sorts of connections in all kinds of education. Continue reading →